60+ Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Looking for a fun and easy way to break the ice at your holiday gathering? “Would You Rather” is the perfect game to bring everyone together, from kids to adults.
With a mix of silly, thought-provoking, and creative questions, this game is sure to spark laughter and conversation at your next holiday dinner or family get-together.
Plus, I’ve included free printable cards to make it even easier to play!
How Do You Play Would You Rather?
“Would You Rather” is simple to play and requires no special setup. Just gather your friends and family, take turns reading the questions, and let the fun begin!
To add a little extra excitement, you can use the free printable cards included in this post.
60+ “Would You Rather” Questions
- Would you rather have a meal without turkey or without dessert?
- Would you rather eat dinner with your family or with a group of celebrities?
- Would you rather go Black Friday shopping or watch football all day?
- Would you rather cook the entire meal or do all the dishes?
- Would you rather have pumpkin pie or apple pie for dessert?
- Would you rather have a meal with no mashed potatoes or no stuffing?
- Would you rather eat only cranberry sauce for a day or only gravy for a day?
- Would you rather run in a turkey trot or sleep in?
- Would you rather have dinner at home or at a restaurant?
- Would you rather have a meal made entirely of desserts or entirely of side dishes?
- Would you rather eat leftovers for a month or never have leftovers?
- Would you rather hunt for your own turkey or grow your own vegetables?
- Would you rather watch the Macy’s Parade or a movie marathon?
- Would you rather celebrate with the Pilgrims or the Native Americans?
- Would you rather have a second helping of your least favorite dish or miss out on your favorite?
- Would you rather wear a turkey costume or a pilgrim costume to dinner?
- Would you rather eat only sweet potatoes for a week or only green beans for a week?
- Would you rather have dinner with your favorite fictional character or historical figure?
- Would you rather have dinner outside or in a banquet hall?
- Would you rather eat an entire turkey by yourself or never eat turkey again?
- Would you rather have a meal without gravy or without cranberry sauce?
- Would you rather watch football all day or help in the kitchen all day?
- Would you rather pluck your own turkey or bake your own pie from scratch?
- Would you rather have a meal without bread or without vegetables?
- Would you rather have a pet turkey or a pet pig?
- Would you rather eat dinner with chopsticks or with your hands?
- Would you rather eat leftovers cold or reheated in a microwave?
- Would you rather go to a big gathering or have a small, intimate dinner?
- Would you rather have dinner with only your immediate family or with your extended family?
- Would you rather only eat holiday food for a year or never eat holiday food again?
- Would you rather have your meal in the morning or at night?
- Would you rather spend the holiday in a cozy cabin in the woods or at the beach?
- Would you rather have to sing the national anthem before dinner or do a dance?
- Would you rather eat stuffing that tastes like cranberry sauce or cranberry sauce that tastes like stuffing?
- Would you rather have your dinner interrupted by a phone call or a knock at the door?
- Would you rather have dinner with your best friend or your favorite teacher?
- Would you rather make a toast or a speech at dinner?
- Would you rather have a meal without pie or without cookies?
- Would you rather cook dinner in a fireplace or on a campfire?
- Would you rather have dinner with a large group of strangers or alone?
- Would you rather wear a pilgrim hat all day or a turkey hat all day?
- Would you rather have a meal that is super spicy or super sweet?
- Would you rather have dinner with your neighbors or your coworkers?
- Would you rather have to watch the same movie every year or never watch a holiday movie again?
- Would you rather only eat holiday food for a month or only drink holiday beverages for a month?
- Would you rather wear pajamas to dinner or your fanciest outfit?
- Would you rather have dinner with your favorite musician or your favorite actor?
- Would you rather do a scavenger hunt or a trivia quiz?
- Would you rather write a poem or a song?
- Would you rather have dinner without any decorations or without any music?
- Would you rather have dinner at a historical site or at a modern venue?
- Would you rather have your meal served buffet-style or plated?
- Would you rather make your own cranberry sauce from scratch or gravy from scratch?
- Would you rather eat a meal with only your favorite side dishes or only your favorite desserts?
- Would you rather have dinner with your favorite cartoon character or superhero?
- Would you rather do a talent show or a fashion show?
- Would you rather eat dinner with a fork or with a spoon?
- Would you rather have leftovers for breakfast or for dinner?
- Would you rather eat dinner outside in the cold or inside in a too-warm room?
- Would you rather share your meal with pets or with wild animals?
Kid-Friendly “Would You Rather” Questions
- Would you rather eat pumpkin pie or chocolate cake for dessert?
- Would you rather have a pet turkey or a pet squirrel?
- Would you rather go on a hayride or play in a leaf pile?
- Would you rather help cook the meal or help decorate the house?
- Would you rather eat only mashed potatoes or only macaroni and cheese for a week?
- Would you rather watch a Thanksgiving cartoon or a movie?
- Would you rather have dinner with your favorite superhero or cartoon character?
- Would you rather play outside in the snow or stay inside and play board games?
- Would you rather wear a pilgrim hat or a turkey hat to dinner?
- Would you rather have dinner with your friends or with your cousins?
- Would you rather eat cranberry sauce or stuffing for every meal for a week?
- Would you rather make a craft or bake Thanksgiving cookies?
- Would you rather play flag football or tag after dinner?
- Would you rather have a big slice of pumpkin pie or a small slice of every dessert?
- Would you rather go to a parade or watch one on TV?
- Would you rather eat dinner for breakfast or dessert for dinner?
Download Your Free Printable Cards
To make playing even easier, I’ve created free printable cards with all of these questions. Just print, cut, and you’re ready to play! They’re perfect for keeping the conversation going during dinner or for breaking the ice at family gatherings.
How to Get Your Free Printables
To download the cards, simply sign up for my email list below. Once you’re subscribed, you’ll get immediate access to this (download button) and other free printables perfect for holiday fun in the subscriber library!
This printable also includes rules, multiple variations to continue the fun, as well as a blank template to create your own game if you want to make it more personalized!
These free printables are a part of our exclusive subscriber library and are for personal use only. They are the exclusive property of Once Upon A Printable and may not be reproduced or used for commercial purposes without our written consent. Thank you for respecting our copyright.
This simple, fun game is the perfect way to create lasting memories with family and friends.
Whether you’re looking to add a bit of humor to your dinner or want a fun activity to keep everyone entertained, these “Would You Rather” questions are sure to be a hit!
Happy holidays!
